Overpressured Shocks on the 5-Car: How Does that Create an Advantage?

The 5 car got sent to the back for the start of the race last Sunday at Dover after qualifying third when their shocks didn’t clear post-qualifying inspection.   Shocks and springs work together to control the rate at which the body of the car moves.  The ideal attitude is the hound dog position:  nose down, tail up, as demonstrated in the photo at right by my capable assistant Darwin.  That position prevents air from getting underneath the car and it sticks the spoiler up in the air as much as possible, which means that more air hits it and creates more downforce.

A spring – one weapon in the setup arsenal –  exerts a force proportional to the distance it is compressed.  A 200-lb-per-inch spring will compress by one inch when a force of 200 pounds pushes down on it, 2 inches when a force of 400 pounds pushes down on it, etc.  You can add spring rubbers to change the rate, but springs are pretty much straightforward tools.

Shocks (the exterior of on being shown at left) are a little more subtle:  They exert force proportional to speed, not the distance.  Shocks are great fun to play with:  they have everything one likes in a mechanical device – lots of tiny little parts that can be put together in myriad ways, adjustments, oil and nitrogen gas.  If you push them slowly, they present some resistance.  If you try to push them quickly, they provide more resistance.  Shocks make a good complement to springs in terms of damping out some of the energy from the bouncing, and for a crew chief, they also provide the ability to tune how the weight of the car shifts during acceleration, braking and turning.

Each team has a shock specialist who works with springs and shocks.  A spring is a relatively simple device:  it’s a metal rod that’s been twisted into a coil.  A shock is much more complex, which means you can tailor the shock much more subtly than you can a spring.  The crew chief will specify what type of behavior he or she wants and the shock specialist’s job is to figure out how to build the shock so that it has that specific behavior.  Shock specialists are an interesting breed.  Most shops have a display where they show which of their shocks were selected by NASCAR for disassembly.  It’s something of an honor.  The dissected shocks are displayed for everyone in the garage to see.

Although  you are only allowed to use a specific set of discs and shims, the number of ways you can combine them is huge, so shocks represent a real degree of freedom for the teams to exploit to gain an advantage.  Although the box that NASCAR allows the team to work within is small, this is an area where a knowledgeable person can make a huge difference for his driver.

From the outside, a shock has a body (shown mostly in brass on the drawing at left) and a shaft (the long silvery part extending downward.   Many racing shocks are made to be rebuilt – the body unscrews.  I’ve diagrammed the inside of the shock at right.  The resistance of the shock to your trying to pull or push on it is because there’s a piston and series of shims that resist moving through the oil the shock is filled with.  The piston is a disk with holes in it.  The shims (the thinner disks that sit on either side of the piston) flex and bend depending of how fast you try to move the shock.  The flexing allows the oil to move through the holes in the piston.  You tune the shock by selecting a piston and shim stacks (one on either side) that determine how easily the shaft moves.  (That’s the macroscopic view – there are a lot of subtleties that I’m glossing over here).

A shock has two motions:  compression, which is pressing down on (or shortening) the shock and rebound, which is elongating it.  You can tune the shock so that it behaves differently on rebound and compression by selecting the appropriate piston and shim stack – you’d like the car to resist compression and return to its fully extended position as fast as possible.

In addition to the piston attached to the shaft, there is a floating piston.  That’s a solid disc with o-rings that seal it to the cylindrical sides of the shock.  If you move the shaft through oil at atmospheric pressure, you incorporate air into the oil.  Very tiny bubbles form, which change the oil’s viscosity.  To ensure that you only have oil in the area where the shaft moves, the floating piston separates the oil.  To keep it pushing on the oil, nitrogen gas fills the space above the floating piston.  The gas is usually filled to a pressure above atmospheric pressure, which pressurizes the oil and creates a force pushing the shock shaft out.  If you compress a shock and then let go of it, the shaft will extend all by itself.  Not quickly, but over a few minutes.  The higher the pressure, the harder it is to compress and the faster it extends.

NASCAR sets a maximum shock pressure.  A closed container under high pressure is called a bomb.  You’re just asking for a seal to blow, a piston to fail and you’ve got a catastrophic failure.  Second, if you let the teams pressurize the shocks as much as they wanted, the rear shocks would essentially be non-moving.  That’s not a great situation:  it puts additional stress on the tires, makes for a very rough ride, and makes the car more challenge to keep under control when it hits a bump.  An over-pressured shock will keep the spoiler up on the air, giving the car an aerodynamic and a mechanical advantage over the other cars.

At New Hampshire, a couple of cars didn’t pass the height sticks in post-race tech inspection.  The teams were allowed to push the cars back around the garage and then the cars passed.  Shocks respond differently when they get hot than they do when they are cold.  If a team doesn’t pass something like the height sticks the first time, NASCAR lets them wait awhile for the car to cool down and settle. It’s much like how the recommended pressure of the tires on your car is specified when the car hasn’t been driven for awhile – the tires need to be cool.  If you fill to the recommended pressure when the tires are how, the tires are going to be underinflated.

It’s very easy to overpressure a shock – gauges may differ, or the shock specialist might be rushing to respond to a last-minute request from the crew chief and miss the target pressure.

5 thoughts on “Overpressured Shocks on the 5-Car: How Does that Create an Advantage?”

  1. , I just read this over on Frontstretch, by Matt McLaughlin.
    “Clint Bowyer probably sent Mark Martin dinner after Martin’s car was disqualified after qualifying for Dover. At least it deflected some negative attention away from the RCR team. Martin’s car was found to have rear shocks with illegally high internal pressures. So, what’s going on? Apparently, the trick to making the car of sorrow handle better is to get the back of the car up further in the air so the rear spoiler is in clean air. To do this during the race some teams, most notably the Hendrick cars that have been dominant over the last few years, are using trick rear shocks. When cold, as in pre-race inspections, the car sits at a legal height. As the shocks heat up during an event the gas within them expands, raising the rear ride height. The car might not pass the height stick test immediately after the race, but given a half-hour to cool off at rest the gas contracts and the car returns to legal height. Apparently, some other teams figured out what HMS was doing and have tried to mimic it. Now, some are getting caught. It’s the same deal as back in the ’90s when first Harry Gant, then Bill Elliott’s Junior Johnson-equipped team figured out the advantage of camber on the rear wheels. Once the secret was out, NASCAR banned it.”
    Someone commented the following, “Isn’t it logical to think that the shocks on Mark’s car are on Johnson’s? I guess we’ll never know for sure. I guess they’ll let Johnson’s car settle before they measure it.”
    Last week someone posted that, “No sane person ever believes any Hendrick car is legal.” To which I replied, “Junior’s is. :)”

  2. The bigger question is will Mark Martin face the same penalties as Clint Bowyer did? If not why? Is it because Mark is not in the chase or is it the fact he races for Daddy Deep Pockets, Rick Hendrick?

  3. It saddens me that a lot of NASCAR fans still don’t understand NASCAR. Mark wasn’t subject to the same penalty as Clint b/c this was not a COT-specific violation. To be clear, a COT-specific violation deals with things like the chassis and body and safety innovations. It does not deal with shocks, wheels and tires, engines, and the like. If the violation has anything to do with specification of the chassis or body it will get hit hard. That doesn’t mean other things won’t get big penalties, it does mean that not everything will be a big penalty.

    The old “problem” (in quotes b/c they were not illegal at the time) with the HMS shocks was the construction. There was not a problem with the construction of Mark’s shocks. They just had too much pressure. It’s mostly analagous to a team not meeting minimum requirements for tire inflation. You fix it, take the most immediate penalty that is available (loss of qualifying position, held of a lap to fix it, whatever).

    Using this reasoning, since the advent of the COT, I have yet to be wrong on what NASCAR has deemed a COT-specific violation and what it has deemed not a COT-specific violation.

  4. Shocks are one of the few “grey areas” left in the NASCAR rulebook that truly great crew chiefs and shock specialists can create a huge advantage for their cars. NASCAR rules mandate maximum pressure as well as an acceptable cool-down period for the shocks to settle. At Richmond, the 48 and the 11 initially failed, but passed after the allowed cool-down period, meaning the presure charge was within the rules – all of which is allowed in the rules. The 5 simply failed in Dover, and though there has never been mention of a cool-down period, you can be darn sure the 5 car received the maximum time allotment prior to being deemed illegal.

    Each of the Hendricks teams has their own crew chief and their own shock specialist – there is no way that the 48 and the 5 are running the same package. Team information sharing only goes so far. Knaus and his bunch are masters of this “dark art” and I believe when looked at 20 years from now, history will show just how far ahead of everyone else Knaus was.

    Whether sensible or not, COT violations are totally different, and have been, and will continue to be debated. There is a window for tolerance on each measurement, and the 33 was out side of the tolerence. How or why is anyones guess. NASCAR has made the COT their sacred cow, and the hammer will continue to come down on anyone who steps over the line.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: