Cautions and Yellow-Flag Lead Changes

Lead changes are frequently used as a way to measure how ‘good’ the racing is. But yellow-flag lead changes aren’t all that exciting. Even worse, they skew the statistics because a race with a lot of cautions will likely have a lot of lead changes.

In trying to evaluate the impact of the 2019 rules package, I hypothesized that what we really should count are green-flag lead changes, but before I went to all the trouble of separating them out, I wanted to be sure that it would really make a difference.


The more cautions, the more yellow-flag lead changes there will be. A race that happens to have a lot of cautions might look like a better race because it has more lead changes, but actually, the majority of the lead changes take place off the track.


I plotted yellow-flag lead changes as a function of the percentage of the race run under caution (which is essentially caution laps corrected for the track length). I used percentage because otherwise races of different lengths end up being weighted differently.

A scatter plot showing a correlation between the percentage of the race run under caution and the number of yellow-flag lead changes
Data are taken from races from 2010-2019 at tracks from Atlanta to Dover alphabetically, excluding Daytona.

I plotted data for racetracks alphabetically up to Dover (excluding Daytona) and stopped there because I think it’s clear that there is a trend.

It’s not a simple correlation because the length of each caution determines whether it’s possible to have more than one lead change as people pit. A quickie caution may not allow time for any lead changes. While you may one or two lead changes during a six-lap caution, that doesn’t mean you’ll have three or four during a 12-lap caution.


More cautions mean more yellow-flag lead changes. Yellow-flag lead changes aren’t what we’d call ‘good racing’, so what we ought to be comparing are green-flag changes.

The number of cautions can have a big impact on the number of ‘quality’ lead changes, so it’s worth the trouble to separate them out.

Please help me publish my next book!

The Physics of NASCAR is 15 years old. One component in getting a book deal is a healthy subscriber list. I promise not to send more than two emails per month and will never sell your information to anyone.

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.